Author | Outcome | Follow-up | Results Comparison and reference groups | Association (95% CI), p value | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Orlando et al 1999 | Pap result lower to higher grade lesions | 6 months; 114 days (median) | CD4+ <200/mm3 vs. CD4+ ≥ 200/mm3 (all women on HAART) | OR 2.18 (95% CI and p-value not reported) | Unclear (incomplete reporting) |
Schuman et al 2003 | Pap result of LSIL, HSIL | 4 years (median) | HAART vs. no ART | OR 1.5 (0.90 - 2.49), p 0.12 | HAART has no impact on progression of SIL |
Paramsothy et al 2009 | Pap result: Normal to ASCUS, ASCUS to LSIL, LSIL to HSIL | 2 years for women on HAART, 2.7 years not on HAART | HAART vs. no HAART | HR 0.7 (0.6 1.0), p >0.05 | HAART has no impact on progression of SIL |
Lillo et al 2001 | Pap result: Normal to LSIL or HSIL and LSIL to HSIL | 15.4 months (median) | HAART vs. no ART, adjusted for CD4+ | OR 2.01 (0.44 - 9.20), p 0.36 | HAART has no impact on progression of SIL |
Del Mistro et al 2004 | Pap result: "persistence or worsening" | 49% followed for >3 years | HAART vs. no ART | 19/36 (53%) women vs. 8/16 (50%) women, p NR | Unclear (incomplete reporting) |
Minkoff et al 2001 | Pap result: Normal to ASCUS, ASCUS to LSIL, LSIL to HSIL | 6 months: consecutive paired results on each participant | HAART vs. no HAART, adjusted for CD4+ and initial Pap result | OR 0.68 (0.52-0.88), p NR | Only study showing evidence that HAART prevents progression of SIL |